This randomized, crossover-controlled study examined the effects of low-carbohydrate, high-fat (LCHF) versus high-carbohydrate, low-fat (HCLF) isocaloric diets on endurance performance, fat oxidation, glycemic control, and cardiometabolic health in middle-aged, competitive male athletes. Over two 31-day dietary periods, participants followed either an LCHF or HCLF diet while maintaining consistent caloric intake and training loads. Researchers assessed athletic performance, continuous glucose monitoring (CGM) data, substrate oxidation during exercise, and a range of metabolic biomarkers.
The study found no difference in high-intensity exercise performance between the two diets, despite a significant shift in energy substrate utilization. The LCHF diet led to record-high rates of fat oxidation during exerciseāpeaking at 1.58 g/min, with 30% of participants exceeding 1.85 g/mināfar surpassing previously documented rates. This shift was accompanied by significant reductions in mean and median blood glucose, glucose variability, and markers of glycemic instability. Notably, 30% of participants had pre-diabetic glucose values while on the HCLF diet, all of which normalized under LCHF. These same individuals also experienced the largest improvements in fat oxidation and glycemic control, suggesting a strong relationship between metabolic flexibility and dietary carbohydrate restriction.
The LCHF diet was also associated with higher total, LDL, and HDL cholesterol, but without negative changes in other cardiometabolic markers such as fasting insulin, hsCRP, or HbA1c. Body composition remained stable across both dietary phases, indicating that observed health and metabolic improvements were independent of weight loss.
Overall, the study challenges the long-held belief that high-carbohydrate diets are essential for high-intensity endurance
performance. Instead, it demonstrates that, after an appropriate adaptation period, an LCHF diet can support equivalent performance while offering significant improvements in fat metabolism and glycemic control. These findings have important implications not only for athletic populations seeking metabolic efficiency but also for broader public health strategies targeting insulin resistance and pre-diabetes in active middle-aged adults.